Help in Suffering

Consortium Implementing Partner

Help in Suffering

Jaipur, India

Help in Suffering (HIS) is the Consortium Implementing Partner (CIP) for the Global Dog Campaign in Jaipur, India.

 

Jaipur is the capital city of Rajasthan state and is the tenth largest city in India. Its population (3,909,333 people in an area of 467 square kilometers – a density of 8,400 residents per Km) grew at over 4% a year in the 1990s but population growth has slowed this century.

 

History

HIS was established in 1980 by Crystal Rogers, a British ex-patriate. In 1991, Christine Townend, an Australian animal advocate, moved to Jaipur to take over the management of HIS. Two years later, HIS was approached by the World Society for the Protection of Animals (WSPA – now World Animal Protection) to test the Guidelines for Dog Population Management that WSPA had produced in cooperation with the World Health Organization. HIS prepared an Animal Birth Control (ABC – street dog sterilization) plan to create a friendly, stable, rabies-free street dog population which WSPA then agreed to fund.

 

Street dog in Jaipur The Project

In November 1994, the HIS-ABC pilot project was launched in the “pink” city area of Jaipur (the central city around the palace). The project was not only a test of the dog management guidelines, it was also launched to prevent further municipal attempts to control the street dog population by poisoning (an approach that had demonstrably failed because the street dog population was not declining).

 

HIS has continued to support the project to the present. Remarkably, HIS has collected street dog population data from 1997 onwards and has a complete set of records of dog sterilizations and dog vaccinations going back to 1994. HIS is one of the few animal organizations in the world to collect and publish time-series data on their activities over twenty-five years. These data document the following:

 

  • Sterilization and rabies vaccination of street dogs rapidly (within eight years) led to the elimination of human rabies in the city.
  • Within a few years, over 70% of the female street dogs had been sterilized. A 70%+ sterilization rate of female street dogs has been maintained since 2002.
  • Over the course of 20 years following initiation of the project, the actual street dog population of Jaipur halved but, in relation to the expanding human population, the relative street dog population (dogs per humans) dropped by 75%.
  • The rate of dog bites treated in medical facilities in the city dropped by two-thirds over the course of the project.
  • A recently published economic analysis of the impact of the HIS dog sterilization and vaccination project documented a dramatic positive return on investment including reduced dog nuisance, reduced human injury and disease and improved dog welfare.

 

Project Development

HIS continues to conduct street dog counts and tracking its dog sterilization program. It is the ONLY humane street dog management program in the world that has collected more than ten years of data on the number of dogs treated, the impact on street dog welfare and numbers, and the impact on human health and community well-being. As a result, we can determine the positive impact of sterilizing around 10% of females annually when such a surgery program is conducted systematically over many years. The percentage of female street dogs sterilized reached 70% six years after the launch of the project. Male sterilization started six years into the project and 70% of males were sterilized seven years later.

 

As the human population grows, the street dog population will also tend to grow in the absence of any management program. In Jaipur, the relative number of street dogs (dogs per 1,000 people) has fallen by 75% since the project started in 1995 (Figure 7:2).

Figure7:1 | Jaipur Street Dog Sterlization Rates alnd Puppy Percentage
Figure 7: 2. Street Dogs per 1,000 People in Jaipur from 1994 to 2017
Figure 7: 3. Index Counts of Street Dogs in Jaipur Center, 1997-2019
Figure 7: 4. Dog Bite Incidence (Bites per 100,000 People) in Jaipur, 1975 -2017

Street dog in JaipurHIS has conducted periodic counts of street dogs on several established routes to track the change in street dog numbers. These index route counts probably only cover one-third to one-half of the street dogs but they provide quick estimates of changes in street dog populations and in changes in sterilization status (percentage of street dogs seen with “tipped” ears). The street dog counts occurred at different times of the year and Figure 7:3 tracks counts done between September and December (before puppy season) and between January and April (during puppy season). The counts during puppy season are higher but both trend lines agree that the street dog population has fallen by 50% between 1997 and 2014. There has been no decline in street dogs from 2014 to 2019. This may be because the pet dog population is growing and unwanted puppies from pet dogs are finding their way onto the streets.

 

 

Global Dog Campaign

 

The HIS project in Jaipur has produced a number of important scientific reports on the impact of street dog sterilization and vaccination on dog and human well-being. In 2006, a scientific report by Reece and Chawla (two HIS veterinarians) documented a decline in human rabies cases to zero following the launch of the sterilization/vaccination project while the number of human rabies cases was unchanged in a control region outside Jaipur. Follow-up papers documented dog surgery outcomes, dog population changes and a two-thirds reduction in the number of dog bites per 100,000 citizens since the project started (see Figure 7:4). Finally, an economic analysis (just published in 2019) documented the community benefits (both in terms of health outcomes and municipal economics) of the HIS project.

 

It appears as though the engagement with dogs in India has been changing over the past decade or so. Private veterinary practices are springing up (fifteen in Jaipur since the turn of the century compared to only the HIS clinic, the government clinic and a clinic at a private veterinary school) and probably reflect a growing human-pet dynamic in the city. Because of the 25-year record in Jaipur, it should be possible to document these human-pet changes in the coming decade.

Related Articles:

Translate »